Why Are Greenhouse Irrigation Booms Moving From DC to AC?
For decades, DC motors were the standard way to run irrigation booms, and many are still doing the job well today. But as AC motors and drives have become more affordable and widely available, the industry is gradually moving toward AC. The shift brings more consistent boom speeds, easier access to parts, and a better connection to modern greenhouse controls.
Why Were Booms Built With DC Motors in the First Place?
For the last 35 years, DC was simply the cheaper way to control speed. DC motors were inexpensive, and running them at a variable speed was easy.
The trade-off was consistency. Speed could vary from one motor to the next, and the industry accepted that as the cost of doing business.
AC motors paired with variable frequency drives started showing up in the late 1990s, but they were expensive. Andrew Van Geest, Technical Irrigation Lead at AdeptAg, compares it to flat-screen TVs: they cost a fortune when they first came out, and now they’re everywhere and affordable. AC drives followed the same path. As more industries adopted them, prices came down.
Why Is the Industry Moving Away From DC Now?
The short answer is parts. As AC took over, the DC market started fading out.
“You have less vendors making that equipment,” Andrew says. “The ones that are left are raising the prices until the sales don’t make sense anymore, and they won’t be carrying them either.”
Some DC components are still out there. If a grower wants to replace a controller with the same one they had, that can still work for now. “But those days are numbered,” Andrew says.
This change is happening across the whole industry, not just with one supplier. At AdeptAg, we talk with about 10 growers a week about moving from DC to AC, and other boom manufacturers are having the same conversations with their customers
Does an AC Motor Change How the Boom Waters the Crop?
Not in a way you’ll see overnight. The real difference is confidence that your settings mean the same thing on every boom.
“When you select 20% speed on an AC motor, it will be the same speed on every boom. Twenty percent will truly be 20%,” Andrew says. On DC, the actual speed can swing 3 to 5% from the setting.
For growers running a range full of booms, that means the same program delivers the same result in every bay.
What About Maintenance on DC Booms?
DC motors have brushes that need changing, or eventually the whole motor gets replaced. Andrew calls that general maintenance, not a real problem. The bigger issue isn’t the wear. It’s finding and paying for the replacement parts as DC supply dries up.
What Does the Switch to AC Actually Involve?
In most cases, it’s more than swapping a motor. A boom’s drive system has three parts:
- Controller: where the grower sets the program
- Control box: carries the DC communication and power to the motor
- Motor: drives the boom down the bay
The controller is built for either DC or AC, not both. The DC controller sends signals to the DC control box, so moving to AC means replacing all three. The good news is that the boom itself, the frame, rail and mechanics, usually stays.
What Should Growers With Older DC Booms Do?
If your DC booms are running fine, you don’t have to change anything today. But it’s worth planning before a failure makes the decision for you.
Here’s the approach Andrew sees working:
- Upgrade in phases. A grower with 25 booms might move 5 to AC first, then use the parts that come off those booms to keep the older ones running a while longer.
- Budget ahead. Put the upgrade into next year’s plan instead of waiting for an emergency repair.
- Know your parts situation. Find out whether replacement DC controllers and motors are still available for your booms, and at what price.
- Time it around the crop. Make changes in the off-season, not in the middle of spring shipping.
What Does AC Make Possible?
Beyond parts and consistency, AC opens the door to tighter integration with the rest of the greenhouse. Newer boom controllers can tie into environmental control computers, which makes it possible to:
- Water based on VPD (vapor pressure deficit) targets
- Water based on moisture content
- Monitor boom cycles
Running DC booms and not sure where to start? Talk to your local rep to help you get started.